💔 Rings of Power continues to disappoint, especially with the latest episode titled "Doomed to Die", which ironically reflects the show's chances of success.
⚔️ This episode should have been a highlight, but it fell short in dialogue, character development, story progression, and overall execution. Instead of an exciting battle, viewers were presented with a confused and tedious mess.
🛡️ Comparing it to the Battle of Helms Deep from The Two Towers, we see a stark contrast in execution. Helms Deep is a tense, action-packed conflict with clear objectives and logical progression.
📍 For a battle to work, it needs three elements:
- A logical battlefield that is easy to track.
- Understandable objectives for both sides.
- A clear sense of progression throughout the battle.
🏰 Helms Deep excels in all three areas. The fortress layout is clear, the defenders aim to hold out until reinforcements arrive, and the battle flows logically with rising tension.
🌪️ In contrast, the Battle of Aon lacks clarity. The geography is murky, and the size of the armies is never fully depicted, leading to a lack of tension.
🤔 The objectives are also muddled. The Orcs want to kill Sauron, while Elrond's forces seem to have overlapping goals, creating confusion.
💥 The progression of the battle is chaotic. The Orcs' strategy to cross the river is nonsensical, and the actions of both sides lack coherence.
⚡ The climax, where Adar leads the Orcs in a final assault, fails to deliver excitement due to unclear dynamics and poor writing.
📉 Overall, the Battle of Aon falls short in every aspect compared to Helms Deep, showcasing the incompetence behind Rings of Power.
👋 That's all for today. Thank you for reading!